This is a true comfort pod that I will turn on and re-listen to multiple times a month. I wish Starlee had had the opportunity for more than one season!

I recommend this show to absolutely everyone I meet, colleagues, neighbors, complete strangers I pass on the street! Such a wonderful show! All the best to Starlee and crew!

Come back to us (current me

Every time I want a new podcast, I just wish this would come back! Absolute gold.

This is really about nothing spread out over the entirety of the show. Highlight was appearance of Jonathan Goldstein . Bring back Heavyweight PLEASE!

This is one of my favorites. It is so good it help calm me down.

Great podcast. Interesting facts and dialog as the investigation unfolds. Please bring back!!!

I loved it when it was on in the beginning and I really wish they would bring it back.

This was such a good show I wish they would have more seasons. The host had the best interviews and made me want to talk to people as she did. So curious, so kind, so perfection. Bring it back!!!

They let this show go for Mysterious reasons so judge for yourself. Google Gimlet Toxic Starlee

love it :)

I re-listen to all the episodes every few years; it’s truly that good. It has the best combination of dry wit and charm out there. Consider a second act!

I’ve listened to this podcast at least once all the way thru every year since 2016 i love her i wish they would bring this show back! it’s so good 10/10

Funny and kind…kept me almost happy through case of flu

I was lucky to listen to this podcast as it was first airing. I loved it so much and still do. I wish it would come back.

It kills me that this was canceled. It makes no sense! It’s so sweet and funny and good and very well-crafted. It’s beautiful. Stop the madness. Bring Starlee back!

We found this podcast too late it seems. My kids and I listened to every episode and loved the way Starly not only solved the mysteries but how she solved them! I wish it had continued!

This pod is everything and I found it too late unfortunately. Starly is wonderful to listen to and love these little unique adventures she goes on to help people close quirky chapters. I need more and I’m so sad it was canceled so quickly.

Love the hosts and the cases they cover. Great chemistry and story telling.

I’m 8 years late to this podcast but it’s such a gem. Helps us to see how deeply connected we all really are if we would just ask questions.

Such a great wholesome fun podcast! I wish Starlee could bring it back. I don’t know what we could do to support her making more episodes but I’m pretty sure we would do it. Mystery Show Episode 8: what happened to the Mystery Show and how do we bring it back?

When I was younger me and my mom would always listen to these episodes, and then they just dropped off the face of the earth.

I love this podcast, because it is uniquely engaging, funny, real, and personable. Plus, this is the only one with mystery stories that doesn’t dive into murder or evil doings. I hope you can do more episodes!

I love this podcast. If you haven’t listened to it yet, do it. If you’ve listened before, listen again.

I loved the personal stories in each episode. And that there was an unexpected twist or deeper meaning to what appeared to be a simple mystery.

This may be the perfect podcast - 5’11.5” perfect

I found this podcast absolutely riveting and totally enjoyable. In each episode a true life mystery is solved. It is so fun to listen to. I wish Starlee would come back and make more episodes!!!!!

Learned about this podcast from Dead Eyes. It is one of the best things I’ve listened to in a long time. It truly does find the magic in everyday life. Just listened to the last episode and the final sign off is so sad knowing that it ultimately gets canceled before the second season. It’s is an all time classic.

Harriet the Spy meets This American Life. Starlee has a talent for storytelling in this refreshingly light & fun podcast. Loved it!

I come here every few years when I’m reminded of that the marching beat of time has slowly made the memory of this great podcast fade. It was 2015 and I was in my car in the subway parking lot on my break from work, eating my Italian BMT whilst mesmerized by Starlee’s unexpected mysteries. It seems like a lifetime ago. This podcast brought me genuine joy to be reminded of all the fun and interesting mysteries out there, and the human connection solving those mysteries could bring. Starlee and Gimlet- PLEASE do at least one more episode.

This is one of those rare gem podcasts that remind you about human connection. I couldn’t get through an episode without getting goosebumps or teary-eyed. Beautiful, simple journalism. Wish Starlee was given the chance to let this podcast grow into something even more.

couldn’t get into it, kinda see why gimlet canceled it.

I love all my gritty real world podcasts. But sometimes on tough days I want to listen to fun stories told in a calm, edited format with a narrator who has a smooth, buttery yet charmingly unique voice. A theme song that feels like sunshine on your face on a warm, breezy spring day is the cherry on top. This is that podcast. It is perfect. Literally the only bad thing this about this podcast is that there are only 6 episodes. The only silver lining to this heartbreak is that they hold up on relisten just like your favorite movie. Starlee, if you ever read these, please create another podcast or more of this one. I would subscribe or signup for patreon for your work. I know I’m not the only one.

This is literally THE BEST PODCAST I have ever listened to. Years later, I still think about the stories Starlee shared. I will fully support all projects Starlee Kine is part of in the future, but I have stopped following all of Gimlet’s other podcasts. And since Gimlet also screwed over the second best podcast ever (ReplyAll with PJ and Alex), they have nothing to offer me anyways.

Originally heard the belt buckle episode and loved it! Especially because I live close to Tahoe. Listened to source code on a road trip and my friends and I were screaming when Jake came on! Wholesome and satisfying! Love the show!

How charming and lovely. Exactly what I was looking for. Delightfully human.

Me too!!! This is hands down THE best podcast that ever was!!! I get super excited when I get to hip somebody who hasn’t heard it yet & seeing their reaction not only warms my heart but proves that it’s not just me, EVERYONE loves this podcast!!! And listening again w/them is a bonus cuz it truly never gets old, in fact it only gets better! Why in the world did they stop making it?!

I listened to this many times. Once I forget I listen again. Absolutely loveeeee it. Starlee where are you?

Certainly favorite podcast ever. I live pretty much everything about these few episodes. I re-listen to them sometimes. Come back here every once in awhile, hoping to find a new one. Imagine that.

10/10 concept, but the host’s personality and demeanor are really distracting. Pretentious isn’t the right word, but somehow pretentious adjacent. Sorry

I love this podcast. I wish there were 1 million more but it seem like every episode must’ve taken a very long time to record and produce. Every mystery is completely delightful. Starlee is fun, clever, and relatable. Do yourself a favor and listen to these.

Starlee’s humor is spot on… this podcast is one of my top 5. I wish there were more

Love it so much!!

I heard about it on the Gavfwst

I heard Starlee in a recent interview say the show may come back. I sure hope it does.

I you guys, I’ve never done this before. I’m usually not that kinda girl. I can’t tell you how much I loved every second of this podcast. I want

Dont cry because it’s over, relisten to the episodes over and over because it happened

I love the timbre of Starlee’s voice and her genuine demeanor. So much fun!

I miss this one.

More, more, more!