I love this podcast, the crazy antics and lack of staying on topic makes it so hilarious to listen to. One minute you guys will be talking about tortillas and the next about the Roman Empire, also food opinion: Hot Cheetos should be dipped in JIF creamy peanut butter. It’s really nice to just sit there and laugh at whatever you guys came up with. te quiero 😘 p.s. this is a ten year old writing this review. children do listen but my parents are fine with cursing though

The best airplane food podcast made me belly laugh. First, Josh says all airports. Major corporations are a conglomerate and needs to be broken up. Then 10 minutes later lady is telling me that this episode is sponsored by United airlines. This is the kind of stuff that makes me want to keep coming back and listening. Love the show guys keep on keeping on. From the best food steak in the country, Louisiana!

I started listening to this podcast back in march, during one of my lowest points in my life, despite the family, and financial problems, I found solace in listening to Nicole and Josh, and their many debates always brings a smile to my face and even laughter. Their shining personalities have enhanced my fascination with trying different foods. Watched mythical kitchen since the beginning! Keep up the amazing work y’all do and nothing but blessings to you Josh and Nicole! From Me (R) and my wife (A) Thank you so much. Love ya Nicole and Josh! Ps. I have the Special edition Pepsi s’mores package that I am willing to donate to the show! Just let me know! Would rather you two or mythical kitchen utilize them instead of sitting on my shelf. -Ruben

Im 13 and i love your podcast. You guys have inspired me to cook more. I grilled my first steak with my dad and i loved it! Anyway, keep up the great work! -Miles

Y’all make me so happy, I always love listening to your podcasts when they come out. I recently found out my friend if a fake tin fish girly 😂 though I’m not a tin fish girly I thought that was really funny. You guys make me smile and laugh and it brightens my whole day. Josh you are friggin’ hilarious, Nicole you are so amazing and kind. Thanks for making this podcast!! Highly recommended!

Love the pod, watch all your mythical channels, and you two together are hilarious. HOWEVER, for the love of food can someone mute Josh's mic when he eats something?!! The amount of noises coming from him when he eats and TALKS WITH FOOD IN HIS MOUTH into the mic is brazy. Love the content overall though

hey, i just tried sardines. i didn’t like them at all. not one bit. in the process of throwing them out, i dropped them all over the floor. just thought i’d let you know. additionally, i wanted to inform you on my new breakfast creation. i really like sausage patties but i'm trying to cut down on fat. so i made patties out of ground turkey, i threw louisiana hot sauce and sugar free maple syrup over them and boom - breakfast has been served. would you do this? also thanks for entertaining me for who knows how long. cheers.

I love Josh’s stories, humor, and knowledge of food. He is the reason that I started and continue to listen to this podcast. I started watching People vs. Food on YouTube and would get Mythical Kitchen as a recommended channel, particularly after he appeared on one of their episodes. I didn’t watch Mythical Kitchen until I started listening to the podcast on a whim. I was looking for a new podcast to listen to, and this came up. Nicole is alright, but Josh is the highlight of this show.

It’s too bad, the topics and conversations are incredible; the hosts, not so much. Most insufferable pair of annoying normies you could ever hope to (not) find a microphone. People like this is why I avoid LA like the plague. Not for me. But you’ll probably enjoy it.

I love the show but I wish you guys did more of the topics you used to do like the blank vs blank those are my favorite, but you guys are great you make me love food and asking questions about food!!!!!!

Let me paint a picture for you: you’re 22, driving home from your last marine biology field lab, the final credits you need to finally graduate community college. It was to see elephant seals in San Simeon CA. You look down and see that you’re dangerously low on gas so you pull over into the small town on the route back home so you don’t get stranded. After pumping, you decide to get dinner at this a local Firestone Grill knockoff. Somehow you find yourself sitting alone in a corner table. Your 9 dollar grilled cheese? Disgusting. Cell service? Nonexistent. The only piece of media downloaded on your device is…Mythical Kitchen. You sit and eat your awful grilled cheese and listen to Mythical Kitchen as you look out on the Pacific Ocean. You leave that restaurant a new man. I’d been listening to mythical kitchen/other gmm podcasts for a while, but truly, listening to Josh and Nicole have strong opinions, argue with love and honesty share genuine culinary joy has inspired me not only to cook more, but care more about the food I make and eat. I cannot recommend this show enough, and I also cannot stress enough how bad that grilled cheese was. Why do places like that insist on making grilled cheeses with brown bread? Thanks so much for everything you do!

i was gonna rate this show 5 stars anyway but i was watching the mythical kitchen “chunnel” and josh said nicole loves gogol bordello which makes me love her even more. keep up the good work guys. you make food sound delicious even when i’m feeling nauseous so like keep doing that :D

I have been listening and watching since the very beginning of the Mythical Kitchen and Hotdog is a Sandwich. They have had great guests, interesting topics, and consistency overall. The reason it is not five stars is only because of Nicole. She is overbearing as her role of a “pick-me” girl, or one of those girls that acts dumb in order to get laughs or attention. This has happened even more after her wedding, with a toxic relationship forming between the content and her need to feel accepted. I love Josh with his informative but curious attitude, and his positive-for-all joke style. It doesn’t feel like his intent is to be popular or fend off personal issues like with Nicole. He shares about his life in order to stay positive, while she shares to get sympathy or to get attention. I’ll still continue to listen and watch videos for now, but beware of the personality traits that come with this podcast.

A hot dog is basically a white guys taco Change my mind 🌮🟰🌭

I enjoy foodie podcasts and downloaded this program today. I can’t take anyone seriously recommending kitchen gadgets if they don’t know what a crockpot is! Deleted.

Love the cast and hot take I like soggy cereal

Plz

I love Josh and Nicole and Jamie. This podcast is both satisfying to listen to and super informative. I never miss an episode.

In each episode, you’re guaranteed to laugh, be entertained, and learn something new about food science or history. One of my favorite podcasts!

… a hot dog NOT being a sandwich, I fully recommend this show. A sandwich allows the chef (or sandwich artist or constructor) to customize the product by including precise amounts of the sandwich’s main ingredient and you CAN"T do that with a hot dog.

Please bring back more food history in context to these silly debates. I love Josh’s history rants! Would be nice to get more substance from Nicole too. I feel like her part as host is a little empty. Earlier podcasts were better but I’m hanging out still with hope.

Thank you SO much for this podcast. Every episode puts a big dumb smile on my face 😁

I love this podcast. I hope they do an episode on sourdough bread or something like that.

This show is awesome and I look forward to listening to each new episode! The hosts are intelligent and knowledgeable about all of the topics they discuss. I love how funny they are as well! They are also two of the most caring people and they are so kind to their fans! Thank you for all of the great shows!

Love the podcast! I listen to y’all a lot at work and at sometimes in the car. It can be hard sometimes not to laugh when I listen at work🤭 I do have a question that maybe could be an episode topic. Are vegetables real? I keep seeing info pop up lately that vegetables don’t really exist. That they can be classified as other things. What do y’all think about it?

Typically, tanner stage two onward.

We need more Meggy!!! the people lover her have her come on the show more often

I have listened to the podcast from the very beginning. lol, I’ve discovered my favorite time to listen is when I’m just laying out and soaking up the sun rays (yeah yeah, skin cancer, sun, I was a lobster child every summer of my youth, that damage has already been done, let me absorb my vitamin D in peace! lol) . During the winter, I listen usually when my stupid ADHD brain wakes up at 4am w some song playing so loud in my head, I can’t go back to sleep. 😊 it’s funny, it’s informative, and you get weirdly invested in Josh and Nicole’s lives. Give it a shot, I ❤️ this podcast!

as I lay here recovering from lasik I go through dozens of hot dog is a sandwich episodes to cheer me up… while pretending the tears are from laughing too hard. it’s the only podcast that makes me feel calm and happy, while learning something and not feeling like i’m wasting my time

It needs more Meggie. The people love Meggie. (Great podcast! Super interesting topics, awesome hosts, always a good vibe. You might not think you’ll learn anything new, but Nicole and Josh always have some cool fact or story that you’ve never heard. Listen to the podcast! Watch Mythical Kitchen! You won’t regret it!)

Just why would we ever need to know this

u guys are so good at taking things i would never care about and making it interesting and fun <3 xoxo

Listening to this podcast is like going to the grocery store: you should NOT do it while hungry. That said, it is fantastic to listen to two intelligent, passionate, and hilarious coworkers share their thoughts about food. I love the things I learn by listening to this, even if it does make me exceedingly hungry.

Can we all just admire how much Josh knows like dude is a literal encyclopedia 😀

You can’t jelly a wiener down your throat! Wakawakawaka Ur welcome

The episode where you talk to Dan Pashman was serendipitously timed. I just got my copy of the Mythical Cookbook and planned to enter a macaroni and cheese contest with Cascatelli pasta next weekend! I was one of the people who preordered it back in the day, and love using it for dishes, and I took aspects of Nicole’s classic for my preferred mac & cheese recipe. Now the only question is “Do I make ‘Animal Style’ to really swing for the fences, or ‘Crustacean and Cheese’ to have fun with that shrimp-like noodle structure? Anyway, great topic and great guests abound with this podcast. And I need to rate it 5 stars because it’s worth it, not just to balance out all the St. Louis based hate that the show manages to accrue, lol.

Not so much a review of the podcast, which I absolutely love and listen to every week, but more About Josh’s appearance with Rhett and Link on the Tonight Show. Josh, you seemed a bit nervous and going sockless was definitely a choice, but I couldn’t be more proud of you. To see the rise of mythical kitchen, you and your incredible staff, the production of a beautiful cookbook, and to top it off with such a fun nationally televised appearance is amazing. Congratulations to you and to all those who helped you get onto that couch. Good job guys!

I recently transferred to a 4-year university that’s about an hour+ away from my house, so of course I need good material to listen to while I drive. Recently SoCal has been having crazy weather, so having this podcast made me feel less lonely and scared while driving in random storms. It’s like I have them sitting in my car and we’re all just giggling over the different food opinions that get brought up. I also tend to create my own opinions like im on the show, then I relay these opinions to my boyfriend. Anyway! Highly recommend this podcast <3 love you guys heheheh

Thank you for making podcast, but you were wrong about something you said that my name that banana bread came from a trend, and what you said makes sense, but you’re wrong! It came from the fact that you ate that one banana bread years ago, and never found the exact recipe ever again and then you got sad because every single time you ate banana bread it didn’t taste the same or better and then you gave up on trying to find that same recipe and then you gave up on it. It popped up again and then you just got confused. this review wasn’t to explain no it was just to leave you with more confusion but I do love your podcast and your YouTube channel It’s great. by the way, you said that when I explained in Subway versus Jersey Mike’s.

I was originally going to rate this 5/5 because Nicole said teachers should be paid more. But no more than 5 minutes later Josh is saying teachers should be paid less. So then I was going to give 1/5. But then again, Josh said he was joking. Classic Josh move. Love the pod!

This podcast has inspired me to cook more and be more open to trying new foods. I’m constantly impressed by how much knowledge Nicole and Josh have of different cultures’ food. I actually think Josh might be more Filipino than I am.

Since we are trauma dumping. I watched Mythical in high school (2014-2016) and when I got to college I stopped. How dare I!? My ex would watch YouTube all the time so I then started to watch YouTube again. He didn’t like mythical smh. Although the relationship did work, I am so glad I got back to Mythical and get to watch you guys speak about food! Highlight of my day and week. 💓

Although I do watch a random subset of Mythical shows on YouTube, I wait on baited breath for my Wednesday drive. I love this podcast because I get to imagine the facial expressions and what Josh and Nicole look like while doing it. It amuses me to imagine Josh with the old school curly locks with the super rad headband. I also am seeing Nicole’s cocoa colored skin with deep brown eyes and the red lipstick lips. Keep doing what you’re doing and I’ll keep listening. Sometime I learn a few things too.

Welcome to everyone’s even more favorite segment, Review A Review Of A Review, where I review Josh and Nicole’s reviews of listener reviews of A Hot Dog Is A Sandwich. I give their reviews of reviews 4/5 stars. They are usually fun to listen to, often pretty funny, but there is not enough practical advice on how to make reviews better for me to give them a perfect score. Cool podcast though

Yes

A Hotdog Is A Sandwich is a podcast that is both educational and entertaining. I have learned so much about food from the fabulous and hilarious hosts that are Josh and Nicole. I have learned about more food content in my entire life just by watching their podcast. Thank you so much for all that you do and look forward to seeing your bright and shining faces every Sunday. 🥰🥰🥰

What’s up Josh and Nicole, been a long time fan of mythical kitchen, and of course the podcast as well! Josh, more South Africa bru. I lived there for 2 years and the world needs Nando’s - superior to El Pollo Loco (for example) all day. Also, you kinda look like Robert Irvine, which is awesome because you’ve had him on the show. Nicole, you’re very pretty and also you have a great laugh! Thanks for all you bring to the show, including your kosher & family food references. Lastly, expiration dates are a scam and most condiments are better unrefrigerated.

Wowzers this is a good show. Josh does an amazing job at balancing both humor and education. While Nicole brings a flare that complements the rowdiness and brings the show back down to Earth. I’ve listened to this show since Day 1 and every time it has brought a smile to my face. Mythical Kitchen is a great watch as well! Please forgive me Sire for my mistake on the branding 🫥

I’ve been listening to this podcast since 2021 and it is absolutely the best podcast I’ve listened to in a long time. I have a question for Josh, Nicole (and the guest if there is one). If you can only eat one type of meat for the rest of your life what would it be? Thanks love the podcast.

Love all the subjects that Josh and Nicole talk about every week, they kinda remind me of a fun Mother Father relationship where they’re trying to be cool, and I’m totally down with it, keep up the good work guys and if this happens to be featured in the rate that review segment, Josh is like a box of chocolates, u never know what ur gonna get when he opens his mouth ❤️❤️