Betrayal

4,006

The Betrayal community is growing. From the producers that brought you the critically acclaimed Betrayal limited run series, a new always on docuseries will hit the feed every week. Our lives are all built on an invisible force: trust. But sometimes, the people we trust the most can turn out to be complete strangers. Every week, Betrayal: Weekly will share first-hand accounts of broken trust, shocking deceptions, and the trail of destruction they leave behind.  Hosted by Andrea Gunning, this weekly ongoing series digs into real-life stories of betrayal and the aftermath. From stories of double lives to dark discoveries, these are cautionary tales and accounts of resilience against all odds.

 

Go back and listen to Betrayal Seasons 1, 2, and 3!

 

In Season 1 we follow Jenifer Faison's journey after discovering her husband Spencer Herron's hidden life. A reality TV producer, Jen moved across the country to be with Spencer, a beloved soccer coach and award-winning teacher in Acworth, Georgia. Their seemingly idyllic seven-year marriage abruptly ended when Spencer was arrested under shocking circumstances. Jenifer's quest for closure leads her to confront the truth about her husband through candid interviews with his victims and other affected women. Through these conversations, Jen begins to heal and reclaim her life from the shadow of betrayal. And make sure to check out Betrayal: The Perfect Husband, which follows Jen's story streaming on Hulu. 

 

In Season 2, Ashley Lytton, a suburban mom of three in Utah, faces a life-altering revelation about her husband. His shocking crime not only jeopardizes their safety but thrusts Ashley into a relentless quest for justice and protection for her daughter. Through Ashley's harrowing journey, the season exposes a pervasive issue affecting families nationwide, shedding light on a betrayal that undermines our core values and communities. And make sure to check out Betrayal: A Father's Secret, which follows Ashley's story streaming on Hulu. 

 

In “Betrayal” Season 3, Stacey Rutherford thought she met her soulmate when she laid eyes on Dr. Justin Rutherford. They fell in love, and it was better than she ever imagined. But this family doctor, beloved father, and cherished husband had dark secrets. He had sworn to do no harm but would resort to any means necessary to save himself.  

Recent Episodes
Episodes loading...
Recent Reviews
  • Lostintranslation🦥
    More Please
    I’m so addicted to this show! Good to know I wasn’t the only one who fell for the wrong dude.
  • santander99
    Real People’s Stories
    These stories are so compelling and well-told. I’m sad they’re on a break :( I want more
  • LittleLindsayG
    My favorite podcast
    I love all of the detail that goes into each episode! They are all so thoughtful produced and great to bring awareness to others who could possibly suffer consequences from the crazies of the world. I've listened and started to re-listen when I need something reliably good to listen to!
  • Spllums
    Love this show!
    Never had a betrayal but this show is so interesting. Andrea does a great job hosting and I wait every week for a new episode to drop!
  • Gold Teef
    Garbage
    If you like this show, just know this show has no respect for your intelligence
  • J from Marin
    So Well Done!
    I found this pod the other day and I’m addicted! Been binge listening and find each and every survivor’s story to be engrossing and there are also lessons to be learned. Thank you and well done!
  • Lilyh21
    Torrah- edited
    ETA I completely understand and agree that we should not victim blame and that it’s understandable to be a trusting person and that is how you can have healthy loving relationships. I also think it would be super important to recommend that women take some basic steps like checking through phones and laptops occasionally and not putting men on their financials before they’ve known them for several years. This is not the same thing as saying it’s their fault because predators took advantage of them but I still say women saying I would never go through the phone. Go through the goddamn phone before your children get sexually abused !!!! I love the show and haven’t written a review yet but after listening to this episode I have to put in my two cents. It alarms me that she moved directly from this traumatizing experience to a male therapist who she views as helping to heal her by “giving her the terminology“ to understand what had happened to her and how to proceed. This is just another example of her relinquishing herself to another person’s mind and ego, and in this case the Therapist dropped the ball. Placing the blame on Aaron for being a “addict“ is conflating the symptom with the cause. He was a narcissist, a textbook narcissist, who just so happened to have opioid use disorder. Those two things are only tangently related but even if he had been sober he would’ve done the same thing. The fact that she was not alerted to narcissistic abuse being the key factor in this situation is alarming. From the first few minutes I started listening and got the basics I already knew everything that was going to happen: taking her money, making her the primary caregiver of the child, him cheating, him either not being in the military or not having a real injury. I know that because he’s an addict? No- I know that because he’s a narcissist. Addicts in general can honestly be some of the least narcissistic and most wonderful caring people so it’s alarming that she has been led to frame this as it was just another dopamine hit. Please “torrah” if you read this you need to look up surviving narcissistic abuse and find counselor who specializes in it, and join the online community of mostly women but some men who have survived this exact scenario. You ended your episode by saying how hard this would be to believe but all of it is completely predictable and normal for those of us who are the slightest bit familiar with narcissistic personality disorder. If your therapist didn’t identify that as the core issue they are not qualified to lead you through this journey of healing. Please consider seeing a female therapist in the future as well. wishing the best for your recovery.
  • CubieBabe
    Why am I listening to this
    So uninteresting…seems like it’ll be true crime but then it’s like boring relationship stories where nothing happens and the stories are super meandering with unnecessary details
  • TC Junkie
    Difficult but necessary. Riveting
    Nobody wants to think this could happen to them, but the truth is much more common than we want to admit. BRAVO to this podcast and guests for sharing their stories. Unfortunately, a must listen. None of us are immune. I’m really enjoying the Betrayal weekly series. I love her storytelling style and people and what they’re capable of continues to shock me week after week.
  • GTFOGirl
    Good people
    I absolutely love this podcast! I’ve learned that the nativity of a good heart can be taken advantage of and just because you have a good heart and were raised well doesn’t mean that all people in the world are good. This podcast just proves that monsters are real.
  • nicwksl
    I love this podcast
    I can’t wait for every new episode to pop up each week. I’m bummed that I have to wait until May for new episodes. The last episode about Jan was excellent, it could’ve even been in a two-part episode, I definitely wanted more.
  • CMC FL
    "Tell Stories to make connections" by Hannah
    I am currently at a national sales meeting getting ready and listening to this show. this story resonated with me. This story not only pertains to my personal life and also my work life. We tell our story to make a connection with people so that they can resonate with the same story.
  • marinaxander
    Jenifer and Spencer
    I just finished the first story of Jenifer Faison and Spencer Herron. When interested in a story, I research diligently. I found that many people, both men and women, were “disgusted” (highest shared word) by how Jenifer questioned the victims and spoke about them, as well as some victim shaming under the guise of empathy and making peace. I myself thought the opposite and was surprised people thought that about her. I thought she was truly empathetic, healed, and seemed like she didn’t hold any anger in her heart for the victims. Then the story continued and I came to realize what they had all realized. She constantly spoke about how she forgave these women, feels for them, etc., but blatantly obviously still holds anger and even some blame towards them. I think she was a women who was so blinded by love that she didn’t want to believe that love was faulty. I think she knew something was up but didn’t want her “perfect marriage” to end, so she simply turned the other cheek, and made herself believe the delusion that everything was wonderful. The “friend” victim said she very obviously saw how Spencer was with other women, and other comments by other victims pointed to the same thing. That means it was obvious to people outside of the marriage that he wasn’t faithful, which when one is cheating to such a drastic extent, with so many women, OBVIOUSLY people are going to be able to notice at times. You mean to tell me someone outside of the marriage noticed, but his own WIFE didn’t see ONE single thing that ever made her question him internally? I don’t think so. The only way that could ever possibly happen is if someone is in true denial, thus creating a delusion of a perfect marriage, perfect husband. I know this from first hand experience. To further my point, the way she still speaks about “Spence” (still using his pet name after all of this, and more) and is being passive aggressive towards certain victims with too many examples to write down, it shows people how she’s actually feeling versus what she’s saying she’s feeling. It’s anger. It’s internally hurt, passive aggressive anger. I truly hope she eventually does find real peace and that she can let go of that anger and hurt because it will continue to eat her alive if she doesn’t. She will not be able to have good relationship if she doesn’t let this all go, and everyone deserves a safe love. I have been through it myself and wouldn’t dare make a series about it until I was truly over it, which she clearly isn’t and that is why people can see that as each episode progresses.
  • Hogshead3au
    Don’t miss an episode
    I had a professional betrayal and hearing these stories and the resilience of the story tellers is cathartic. Thank you!
  • LC51281
    Why was Hannah’s story told?
    Why was Hannah’s story an episode at all, much less a two-part episode?! Yes, it’s awful that her husband cheated on her with her best friend, but no crime was committed. Did the Betrayal team run out of stories?!
  • alkyriag
    Last Hannah episode a miss
    I love this podcast and it knocks me off my car. This last one that was 2 parts, what was this? Nothing outrageous or rare? I have no idea why cheating with a best friend needs two parts?
  • valandvin
    Poor little ME
    This latest series on Hannah is pure drudgery. She’s obsessed with her ex and just as insecure and sad as he portrays in his “fictional” book. At least there was some self awareness near the end of her responsibility but hopefully she’ll move on and get over it.
  • Meljojola
    Why in the world
    Did we need 2 podcasts to let us know that someone’s husband cheated on them with their best friend. I could’ve seen that on a Facebook group with out the whole life story lasting an hour long. Come on . Also why be friends with him after that. What in the actual…
  • Fredrick560
    Love it but less interruption
    Absolutely love this podcast but the host interrupts the guest too much to say the same thing they are about to say. Please let them just talk and interject when a dramatic moment comes up.
  • Scrapgrrrrl
    It’s not just for show
    Just because these seem rote -“rich woman/poor woman, cheated on” you have to realize that these are real people - it’s not just a story. It’s a way to let them tell their story, it’s to remind us that women’s goodness and trust and mothering seem to be taken advantage of and that is wrong and unjust. In real life women vs. men are still mostly the victims of crime, abuse, violence, and inequality. This podcast gives these women a voice.
  • Solotraveler32
    Dramatic
    This podcast is getting a bit too dramatic. There was a story last week when the lady said her relationships didn’t work because the men always wanted more than her and when she met the guy the story was about she said something like finally a man who isn’t a loser. And I’m like you never said anything bad about those other guys before. And ended up choosing the worst of them 🤷🏽‍♀️
  • Mirror_Sea
    Rich lady problems
    It’s either a rich lady or poor one and they are always clueless.
  • Yodogwasgood
    Like crime podcasts but usually without the ethical ickyness
    I’m obsessed. I love the tea from peoples lives that I don’t know. It’s also like crime podcasts but without the ethical murky nature of those.
  • ShaSha827
    Hannah
    . We needed 2 episodes for us to learn that someone’s husband cheated with her friend? So did a billion other men. This was a waste of time I’m sorry.
  • C. Lynn Barton
    Great Podcast’
    Informative podcast which is well narrated.
  • Aims-Moji
    Favorite show!
    Only problem with this show is it doesn’t come out fast enough! There isn’t one episode I didn’t obsess over. Such a great podcast.
  • Kim Gillespie
    Best podcast
    I love your show!!! You give a voice to people who have been so hurt with such compassion!!
  • ElleValdez
    Stories about real-life
    I started watching this series on Hulu, then listened to the podcast series and was glad they added the weekly episodes series to tell more stories. Some episodes are not as good as others as is true for all podcasts. Some are truly heartbreaking. There are those that I want to shake and say, “That wasn’t a huge red flag or you didn’t see that coming?” But at the end of the day, people are often blinded by love and a sincere desire to see and want the best in and for others. No one deserves to be scammed, lied to, or hurt by the people who are supposed to love them.
  • NurseRebecca
    Enjoying your podcast
    Thank you for sharing these stories and most of all, empathizing with your guests
  • Glitzbglimmer88
    Really interesting stories!
    Love listening to these stories while I drive
  • OofiOofster
    All except one
    I have always enjoyed this podcast, brilliantly co-told by the host, it feels important that people tell their stories & they can be an important warning to us all. However, the episode with the "journalist" & commander seemed like satire. From beginning to end the storyteller told us how smart she is & how her investigative journalism skills were next to none. WHAT?!?! This is the most ridiculous assessment ever. The only reason she had no clue he was lying was because she herself is such a narcissist, she is clueless to what anyone else was doing. Until the end when she clearly camped out in front of his home to see if the "slather of soap" was stuck to the same tile. What a self absorbed brag piece that episode was. I found all other episodes to be genuinely shocking & disturbing stories that happened to well meaning & optimistic people & I sincerely hope those victims have or can overcome their unfortunate circumstances & live their best lives.
  • Mushi67
    Student loans?
    Love this show but I don’t understand the episode about the student loans. It sounds like the girl had her education paid for through students loans and the big scam was that she doesn’t understand that she would have to be on the hook for them when she graduated? I guess don’t major in music? Huh?
  • eddieG9999
    Good podcast but needlessly splits the stories into two episodes
    This would be a better podcast if they didn’t split the stories up into two episodes.
  • StellaSuzzane
    Abby
    Girl. Osama Bin Laden?
  • praxis78
    Good job
    Interesting stories!
  • 2244356745
    Used to love this podcast
    Now, I mediated delete as soon as someone mentions all the leftist buzz words. Thus podcast used to be sooo good. It almost had a Christian perspective and someone bought it and ruined it. Sorry, deleting. I don't have time in my life to get annoyed by so many people trying to indoctrinate. I can just unfollow. Hopefully you will understand we are done. I gave this one 5 chances. Byeeee
  • Nothanks19
    Gross
    Yall have lost the plot. Now all you’re doing is leaning into the TREND of victimhood.
  • Shananogin
    I changed my rating
    I thought this was a different podcast. It’s actually pretty good.
  • Jess Meggs
    Andrea
    Andrea Gunning is one of my favorites! Every thing she covers is phenomenal.
  • Jeffrey99
    Average podcast
    It’s a average podcast. Semi interesting story. The “expert” in the S1E9 episode is a moron. If you have not listened, here’s a tip: women are always the victim of grooming. They have no responsibility for their actions. If a married woman has a affair with a married man, obviously she had zero control over her body and it’s 100% the man’s fault. The weekly shows should be called: “Missed Ted Flags”. Every week there’s more red flags missed than you can imagine.
  • Davy4657
    Betrayal
    This is one of the best podcasts I’ve found!
  • Nothankssnapchat1
    Mormon factcheck 🙄🙄
    The latest episode drove me absolutely crazy. She portrays the Mormon community as though they are all blonde haired blue eyed Stepford wives. Maybe do some research before doing podcast that broad brushes entire religions. I understand you were trying to make it interesting, but it’s just disrespectful at this point.
  • brainbbbb
    Love
    I love this podcast, and find the hosts narrative bits quite lovely, sympathetic and useful for contextualizing each trauma/betrayal. Thanks for sharing these stories in a respectful and gentle way.
  • Little2ant
    The best
    I love this show and look forward to it each week - I bit the bullet and became a subscriber today. I also plan on telling my own story someday! Great voice, compelling stories ….my fave!!!
  • MrsMink
    Kelsey
    As the story grew. I knew which rabbit hole it was headed. My son survived three cancers before age six. I understood the realities of how cancer and the treatment works. However, what struck me the most about Kelsey, besides her eloquence of telling the story. It was her reflection and her understanding of the hows and whys of what happened that really drew me in. As much as she had hurting her heart, she refused to allow hate to take over. And her ability to describe how she came to these conclusions was very well spoken, and so easy to absorb. All my best to you, Kelsey. I hope life brings you a wealth of happiness.
  • 1sheek1
    Less of you
    I wish we could hear more of the woman talking and less of the host. The you me, you me format is annoying and makes the show hard to follow. LET YOUR GUEST TALK! The show is about them, I feel like you just want to hear yourself talk.
  • Rfhiddyjuv
    Great
    I really enjoy listening to this podcast, while you may think, ‘how did they not get it’ I completely understand how people can make a million excuses for those they love. Don’t hate on the victims, it could happen to you.
  • KatyKat85
    Two Things
    1. Please differentiate between child victims and adult victims. I know there was feedback on the language around “grooming.” Y’all allowed adult women to place themselves on the same level as a child, which is psychological and legally so inaccurate. It dilutes the actually victim/survivors experiences. 2. Do some legal fact checking. Former USAO for Utah is wrong on the state law around CSAM production. There is no mandatory minimum for production of CSAM. UCA 76-5-402.1, 402.3, & 403.1 talk about mandatory prison sentences for the hands-on offense, not production. Utah law even provides for a lesser prison sentence under certain circumstances. Furthermore, those offenses only apply where the victim/survivor is legally defined as a “child,” meaning under the age of 14. Utah is abysmal with sentencing for sex offenses on the state side. Loads of prosecutors seek federal charges in CSAM cases for this exact reason.
  • kathylbc
    Good but annoying host
    I stick with it still bc I like the content (usually) but the style of the host can be grating, her sing -songy rhythm is annoying. Not sure how much more I can take. Like other reviews that one home wrecker lady who married a cheater deserved what she got and the host is playing like she was sympathetic or something. Gross.
  • WhereIsMyMoneyBusyKid
    Just nope.
    Does anyone else listen to these episodes and think “what an idiot?” I can’t believe so many people ignore bright red flags. Yikes. Also half of each episode is ads and it’s SUPER annoying. Trying to jog or work while hitting the skip button 18+ times isn’t fun. I’ll just read the story online omg
Similar Podcasts
Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork on this page are property of the podcast owner, and not endorsed by UP.audio.